Toolkit Lesson for Uncle Tom’s Cabin Vases
created by Alston Cobourn, Elizabeth Teaff, and Ron Fuchs
Uncle Tom’s Cabin pair of vases made in Limoges, France
Possibly decorated in New York, New York, circa 1860
UCAH purchase with funds provided by W. Groke Mickey
“There is no arguing with pictures and everybody is impressed with them, whether they mean to be or not.” -Harriet Beecher Stowe
Details of Artwork from UCAH
This pair of vases was made in Limoges, France, and are decorated with figures from Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin (1852). Limoges was the center for porcelain production in nineteenth century France and this type of porcelain was a popular item for the home in America during the same time period. The vases were purchased by UCAH with funds provided by W. Groke Mickey.
The vases were possibly decorated in New York, New York, about 1860. They were made of hard-paste porcelain which is a combination of kaolin clay and petuntse rock (Clarke). The vases are decorated with vignettes of two seminal moments in the novel; Little Eva hanging flowers around Uncle Tom and Eliza fleeing over the ice with her son Harry. Their large size, approximately 19 inches in height, and elaborate decoration suggest that they were expensive and meant for a grand interior. It may be argued that they are the physical manifestation of the main-streaming of anti-slavery sentiments among much of the United States.
The vases are examples of the rococo revival style popular in the 1850s and 1860s, and they are painted in the color solferino, which is a purple-red color. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, solferino is a dye from Italy which was discovered around 1859. Mary Todd Lincoln chose solferino for the state dinner service she commissioned for the White House in 1861. This article from the New York Daily Tribune details the White House china purchase.
The Novel & Its Influence
Published in 1852, Uncle Tom’s Cabin was the second best-selling book of the century, after the Bible. The novel is often credited with changing the nation’s perception and opinion of slavery. Mythology around this book includes the story that Abraham Lincoln supposedly described Stowe as “the little lady who started this great war” (Weinstein 1). The popularity of the book spawned a wide range of images, theatrical productions, and objects based on the book throughout the nineteenth century and beyond. As a December 23, 1852 article in the abolitionist newspaper The Liberator reported;
“It should be noted, among the favorable signs of the times, that artists, of all grades, now find it not only a congenial, but a remunerative work, to represent the creations of Mrs. Stowe’s genius in pictures and statues. The people of Boston, and of large towns generally, have long been accustomed to see Uncle Toms, Eves and Topsys without number, in engravings of various degrees of merit and price. Lately, they have been in oil colors, by Baxter, or some of his imitators; and now I find not only large engraved heads, in the finest style of Parisian mezzotint, one of Uncle Tom life-size, and another of Eva and Topsy, but a group in real bronze, showing Eva putting the wreath of jasmines around Tom’s neck, and separate statuettes of George Harris, and Eliza and her child. I infer, from seeing these elegant and expensive works in the shop windows with Paul and Virginia, Little Nell, and Undine, not only that the general heart of humanity has been touched by them as by their predecessors, but that they have an established market value, and that people of wealth and taste now begin to seek such works as the ornaments of their parlors and chambers -C.K.W.”
The book was extremely popular in America and abroad and had profound effects; in the 1926 edition of Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Francis Pendleton Gaines states in his introduction, “Within a year, according to Mrs. Stowe, 300,000 copies were sold [in the U.S], resulting in profits to her greater than had accrued to any American from a book” (Stowe x). “By 1857, the book had been translated into 20 different languages, and sold more than two million copies worldwide.” (Uncle Tom’s Cabin: A 19th-Century Bestseller). “In Scotland an emancipation fund of a thousand pounds was raised by penny subscriptions” (Stowe x). In Russia (Stowe x) and Siam slave holders freed slaves because they were so moved by the novel (Stowe x; Warner 320). The novel was even the subject of a U.S. Supreme Court case. In 1853, Stowe sued F.W. Thomas who had translated the novel into German and sold it in the U.S. without the author’s permission. The court ruled that Thomas had not violated Stowe’s copyright because the translation could not be considered the same work (Copyright Timeline: A History of Copyright in the United States). This principle is still upheld in copyright law today.
Toolkit Lesson: TEACHING FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF HISTORY
As background read pages 75-79 of the 2003 article by Kathleen Hulser, “Reading Uncle Tom’s Image: From Anti-Slavery Hero to Racial Insult,” in volume 65 issue 1 of The New York Journal of American History.
For additional background information, read the “Introduction” from Henry Louis Gates and Hollis Robbins’ 2007 book The annotated Uncle Tom’s cabin published by New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Illustrations shape how we see the text of a novel. Imagery can serve as a “representation for ideology” (Fee 37). The meaning of images may shift over time along with the social norms of the day. Compare these vases to images presented in various editions of the text, which can be found at Stephen Railton’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin and American Culture website hosted by the University of Virginia (UVA).
- How are the images on the vases similar to the illustrations you selected? How are they different?
- How have the images changed over time?
- Have the images of the character Uncle Tom changed?
- Given that these vases were meant to be displayed in the home, why do you think these specific scenes were selected?
- Who would have bought something like these pieces, and why?
- What is a representation of a modern social justice movement that has become mainstream?
- Are there other items in the UCAH collection that function in the same manner as these vases? Find one object and write a short essay on your conclusions.
Clarke, Michael, and Deborah Clarke. “Limoges porcelain.” The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Art Terms. Oxford University Press. Oxford Reference. 2010. 9 May. 2016. Web
“Copyright Timeline: a History of Copyright in the United States.” Association of Research Libraries. 4 May 2016. Web.
Fee, S. B. & Fee, T. R. “Visual Archaeology: Cultural Change Reflected by the Covers of Uncle Tom’s Cabin.” The Journal of Visual Literacy. 31.2 (2013) 35-48. Print.
Fenichell, Jill. “Fragile Lessons: Ceramic and Porcelain Representations of Uncle Tom’s Cabin,” Ceramics in America. Ed. Rob Hunter. Milwaukee: The Chipstone Foundation, 2006. Print.
Klapthor, Margaret B., Betty C. Monkman, William G. Allman, and Susan G. Detweiler. Official White House China: 1789 to the Present. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1999. Print.
“solferino, n.” OED Online. Oxford University Press, March 2016. 9 May 2016. Web.
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. The annotated Uncle Tom’s cabin. Ed. Henry Louis Gates, and Hollis Robbins. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 2007. Print
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom’s Cabin. New York: MacMillan Company, 1926. Print
“Uncle Tom’s Cabin: A 19th-Century Bestseller”. Publishers’ Bindings Online, 1815-1930: The Art of Books. The University of Alabama. 4 May 2016. Web.
Warner, Charles Dudley. “The Story of Uncle Tom’s Cabin.” Atlantic Monthly 78 (1896): 311-321. Print.
Weinstein, Cindy, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Harriet Beecher Stowe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. Print.
Websites for Further Exploration
Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Harriett Beecher Stowe Center.
Uncle Tom’s Cabin Historic Site. Ontario Heritage Trust.